Draw a Circle Theologic Review
See a Problem?
Thanks for telling us about the problem.
Friend Reviews
Community Reviews
I am sad to report that this wasn't the case for me. I did like it. It had some interesting and inspiring stories, some great quotes and reminders, and some good suggestions. It was but missing one thing: construction.
What I had expected, needed, a
I wanted to like this book. No, that's not true. I wanted to love this book. Earlier requesting a copy to review, I had read several other reviews get-go, and saw many people talk about how life-changing it was. How information technology had revolutionized their prayer life.I am distressing to report that this wasn't the case for me. I did similar it. It had some interesting and inspiring stories, some peachy quotes and reminders, and some practiced suggestions. Information technology was just missing one thing: construction.
What I had expected, needed, and was hoping for was a linear approach, for want of a better term. To be truly useful to me, and for me to recommend it to others, a book similar this needs to take a staircase approach. Each day's reading, story, theme, etc. should build on the day earlier. Ideally, a set of sub-themes would exist bully for a volume like this (i.due east. Day 1 - x "Press into God", Solar day 11-20 "Centering Your Circle on His Volition", Day 21-30 "An Expectant Circle", Twenty-four hour period 31-40 "Looking Beyond the Possible"���or something similar that).
Unfortunately, each day seemed random. There was no follow-through in theme (across "pray, await an answer, trust God", which was woven through well-nigh of information technology), and no momentum from one day to the adjacent. As a outcome, I didn't feel like I really got anywhere, in part because the book didn't feel similar it was going anywhere.
Having voiced that criticism, there is some other criticism--even rebuke--that Marking Batterson and Describe the Circle have received that I demand to address. Some have connected the "circle cartoon" to witchcraft, while others have insisted that Batterson is promoting a "health and wealth" or a "name it and merits information technology" theology and arroyo to prayer.
Both of these criticisms are patently absurd. No 1 could legitimately read this book and then accuse the author with either of these.
Are circles used in some rituals in witchcraft? Yes. They're also used in geometry, gymnastics, roller coasters, and cooking. Are all of these to exist avoided because they're evidently connected to witchcraft? (If you said "yes," please cease reading now--at that place'south nothing else I tin say to you.) The circle imagery used in this book has no more connection to witchcraft than whatsoever of these others exercise. Batterson uses information technology to make a point, and to assistance provide a somewhat tangible visual for the reader. To me, it did and then effectively.
As for the other merits, that he is promoting a "wellness and wealth" or "proper name information technology and merits it" theology and arroyo to prayer, this is again untrue. Every bit just one example of many, Batterson writes, "God is not your genie in a bottle, and your wish is not His control. His command better be your wish." This is so far from the charge of "health and wealth," etc. that they're not even in the same ballpark.
If you're concerned well-nigh either of these possibilities (witchcraft or a prosperity-gospel), consider your fears assuaged. If you're looking for a book that will revolutionize your prayer life, this may be it. Information technology wasn't for me, but if you lot're non concerned about the scattershot approach, or if information technology works for yous, and then you may find Depict the Circle worthwhile. If aught else, read it and depict some inspiration from some amazing quotes (like the i I shared to a higher place) that may assist change your perspective (in a good way) or provided much-needed reminders.
Disclaimer: I received a review copy of this volume at no accuse, only all opinions are my own.
...moreThis book is amazing; information technology will change your relationship with God, challenge your prayer habits and help shape new patterns for both prayer and devotional time. In the Introduction Mark states "If you desire God to do something new in you, you cannot keep doing the same old matter. You have to do something different. And if you exercise, God will create new capacities within you. In that location will be new gifts and new revelations. Merely yous've got to pray the price. You'll get out of this what you put into it." Then on twenty-four hours 26 he states: "If you lot want God to practise something new in your life, you cannot keep doing the same old thing. My advice is simple: do something dissimilar. And you'll see what a difference it makes!" And once again on day 28 "If you desire God to practice something new, you lot cannot continue doing the same onetime thing." This volume will help break you from the habit of same old same old. The Psalmist in Psalm 51:12 declares: "Restore to me the joy of your salvation and grant me a willing spirit, to sustain me." This book will rekindle your prayer life! Give it a try - you accept nothing to lose and a whole lot to gain.
"In a moment of revelation, the circumvolve maker realized that praying is planting. Each prayer is like a seed that gets planted in the footing. It disappears for a season, just it eventually bears fruit that blesses future generations. In fact, our prayers behave fruit forever."
Then pick up this volume and pray through the twoscore days. Plant new seeds and keep pray hard and thinking long!
Read the review and with links to other reviews of books by the author on my weblog Book Reviews and More.
...moreI wished for more stories of answered praye
Author Marking Batterson uses the metaphor of Drawing a Circle to teach several key lessons well-nigh prayer: Circling back and praying for the aforementioned thing repeatedly, committing to staying in a literal or figurative circle before God to wait for his answers, physically drawing a circle effectually written prayer requests that still need prayer, etc. While the metaphor is a rich one, and well developed in Batterson's work, I was hoping for more depth in other ways.I wished for more stories of answered prayer. Having read the 1890'south classic Touching Incidents and Remarkable Answers to Prayer several years ago, and having been driven to prayer past its overwhelming alluvion of story upon story, I was expecting something in the same vein.
Likewise, equally the volume is promoted as a xl-Day Prayer Challenge, I was expecting information technology to be more of a tool. Other than existence divided into xl chapters (one for each day), the volume didn't require its reader to use it in whatever practical ways. It was more of a 40 Days of Chicken Soup for the Prayer Warrior's Soul. To be more functional, additions similar questions at the end of each chapter with space to periodical, and actual assignments to accomplish each day could have taken the book to the next level.
The fabric presented in
Draw the Circle is good. But the book as it is risks being a feel-practiced read with little lasting bear upon. Fact is, I'grand a lazy reader. I'll skim. I'll chuckle if something's funny. I'll become "hmmm" if it's deep. But at the end of the day, I'll probably forget most of it, unless I immediately practise something with it. Make it "stick to my ribs" by demanding that I apply the material on a daily basis, or you'll probably lose me.I received this book free from the publisher through the BookSneeze®.com book review bloggers program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I take expressed are my ain.
--Jen
...more thanPerhaps my review would be different if I finished it, merely this cruel by the wayside for me. Maybe I
DNF - Although I picked upwardly a helpful tip or two, this book just wasn't for me. Rather than praying for something to happen or something to modify. I endeavor to focus my prayers on praise and thanksgiving. My requests are generally for the well being of the people around me. In that, I do not challenge God to brand something happen, rather, I pray that God'southward good and perfect will be done in their lives.Peradventure my review would exist unlike if I finished it, but this fell by the wayside for me. Peradventure I volition try again one day.
...moreAs a fellow-Christian and double-ly as a fellow five pt Calvinist, I wish I could say I believe the teachings of Mark Batterson are biblical. I read many statements about God's sovereignty and God's glory that my eye delighted over. However, in determination, I must hold with other reviewers that this book is absolutely promoting "prosperity gospel" and sadly, it is wrapped in the well-nigh clever, advisedly-worded mask that I have Always seen. This is non the easily visible greedy "prosperity gospel" of the "Discussion Religion" or "Give-and-take of Faith" cult. This is "prosperity gospel" advisedly masked between beautiful statements of how nosotros are to live our lives trusting in a sovereign God and living to glorify God! How "crafty" was the snake/Satan in the garden. Do not autumn for his carefully bearded lies.
For every judgement, ask yourself "Do these teachings lucifer the Bible?"
"In Luke 11[:5-10], Jesus tells a story about a man who won't take no for an answer. He keeps knocking on his friend'southward door until he gets what he came for. It'southward a parable nigh prevailing in prayer. And Jesus honors his bold conclusion: "... withal because of your shameless audacity he will surely get up and give you lot as much every bit you lot need." I love this depiction of prayer. There are times when you demand to practice whatever it takes. You lot demand to grab agree of the horns of the chantry and not let become. You demand to dare demonic forces to a duel. Yous need to practice something crazy, something risky, something different." Mark Batterson. Draw the Circle (Kindle Locations 496-510).
John Calvin says this poetry ways, "Believers ought not be discouraged, if they do not immediately obtain their desires, ... we have no reason to doubt that God will listen to united states, if we persevere constantly in prayer..." All the same, observe how the warning bells get off in your head when you read Batterson apply this to life by calculation "there are times when y'all need to practice Whatever Information technology TAKES." "You need to cartel demonic forces to a duel." Is this biblical? Although some modernistic day Pentecostals believe we are to "become to boxing with demons", the bible does not teach this. Batterson follows with this example extracted from the Jewish Talmud Scriptures (which Christians very much reject, as the Talmud is written past rabbis hostile towards Jesus) of "doing whatever information technology takes":
"The epitome of shameless audacity is the circle maker himself. When a severe drought threatened to destroy a generation of Jews, Honi drew a circle in the sand, dropped to his knees, and said, "Lord of the universe, I swear before Your great proper name that I volition non move from this circle until Y'all have shown mercy upon Your children." Information technology was a risky proposition. Honi could have been in that circumvolve a long time! But God honored that bold prayer because that bold prayer honored Him. And even when God answered that prayer for pelting, Honi had the shameless audacity to ask for a specific type of pelting. "Not for such pelting have I prayed, but for rain of Your favor, approving, and graciousness." Mark Batterson. Describe the Circle (Kindle Locations 496-510). Zondervan.
Starting time, this is a story from the Jewish Talmud, which includes some bizarre stories and portrays Jesus as a false prophet. We exercise not affirm anything in the Talmud to be a true account on its own basis. So we do non know that God honored whatsoever such prayer/demands from anyone named Honi. Batterson has dangerously gone into the Jewish Talmud and ripped a story out and is using it as a basis for teaching Christian prayer.
"The moral of this parable is to prevail in prayer, but it too reveals the graphic symbol of Him who answers prayer. The asking is not granted simply because of repeated requests. Prayer is answered to preserve God'southward good proper noun. Afterwards all, it's non our reputation that is on the line; it's His reputation. So God doesn't reply prayer just to give us what we desire; God answers prayer to bring celebrity to His name." Mark Batterson. Draw the Circle (Kindle Locations 496-510). Zondervan.
I tin can just see a dozen professing Christians demanding God grant their prayers "or else God will have a bad proper noun." Or going earlier unbelievers and declaring "God will heal your mother or else He will have a bad name!" This is a very dangerous claim and I do non believe that Batterson accurately portrays prayer "for God's glory" as "according to God's will" and "according to God's foreordained purpose that is gear up from the foundation of the world" is nearly always left out of the context.
"Go domicile. Lock yourself in your room. Kneel downward in the eye of the floor, and with a slice of chalk draw a circle effectually yourself. There, on your knees, pray fervently and brokenly that God would start a revival within that chalk circle."
Describe a chalk circle effectually yourself and need that God grant your prayers or yous will non leave your little chalk circle [Batterson teaches the "don't go out" in his The Circle Maker" volume]? How unbiblical and disrespectful and dishonoring of God. How cocky-focused and cocky-centered. Is this how Jesus taught united states of america to pray? What happened to praying according to the Male parent's will?
Dozens of farmers showed upwards to pray [for rain]. Most of them wore their traditional overalls, just one of them wore waders! ...Why not dress for the miracle? I love the simple, artless religion of that old, seasoned farmer. He merely said, "I don't want to walk home moisture." And he didn't. But everyone else did. ...... I can't help simply wonder if that act of faith is what sealed the phenomenon. I don't know for sure, just this I exercise know: God is honored when we human action every bit if He is going to answer our prayers! And acting as if means acting on our prayers. After hit our knees, we need to take a small step of religion. And those pocket-size steps of faith frequently plow into giant leaps. Like Noah, who kept edifice an ark twenty-four hours after day, we keep hammering abroad at the dream God has given u.s.. Like the Israelites, who kept circling Jericho for vii days, we keep circling God's promises. Like Elijah,ten who kept sending his servant back to look for a rain cloud, we actively and expectantly wait for God'due south answer. ...... Don't just pray nigh your dream; act on it. Act as if God is going to deliver on His hope. Maybe it's time to put on waders and human action as if God is going to respond. Mark Batterson. Draw the Circle (Kindle Locations 539-559). Zondervan.
Exactly like the "Give-and-take of Religion" cult that is the principal promoter of the "prosperity gospel", Batterson starts encouraging believers to "accept a step in faith." This is the same faux teaching referred to as "seed religion" by the "name-it-claim-it" grouping. Biblical "trusting faith" is trusting in God to do the all-time thing for you whichever way He decides to answer your prayer. Information technology is not "acting equally if God were going to grant your prayer in the way y'all want it to" as if this "voodo" "heed over matter" could fool God into granting that prayer only as you wish Him to. This is completely unbiblical.
Peculiarly, take notation of Batterson's fake claim: "I can't help merely wonder if that act of faith is what sealed the miracle." Your "acting as if God were going to requite yous your desires" is NOT faith and it does Not "seal" or "grant" or "cause God to move" in any such fashion. This is the unbiblical teaching of "seed faith", "faith-ing-it" or "mind over matter" or "heed over God". It is using your "beliefs" to "fool God/prompt God" to give you what you want.
Immediately next, Batterson makes the bold declaration: "this I exercise know: God is honored when we act as if He is going to answer our prayers" This is completely faux! First, God ALWAYS answers our prayers. Sometimes information technology's a "yes", "no", "afterward" but He ALWAYS answers them. And then "interim equally if He were going to answer "yes"" as if this little "behavior" were to twist God into answering a "yeah" is completely false. Why not act equally if God were to answer "no"? Same logic. This is completely unbiblical.
Like the master of deception himself, Batterson then cleverly slips in "we go along hammering away at the dream God has given united states" [as the Israelites and Elijah did]. Discover that Israel and Elijah were given commands directly from God. "Our dreams" "wants" "desires" are non something God told u.s. to pursue through a prophet. In fact, they are often worldly and contrary to the desires of God. This is why often God'south answers to our prayers is a "no" because our Father knows these "wants" are non for our own proficient.
The number of passages in this volume that teach an unbiblical view of prayer are phenomenal. This book is entirely "prosperity gospel" masked in low-Calvinism. And even and so, the low-Calvinism promoted by Batterson is very tainted with a "man tin influence God through clever tricks" theology.
My disclaimer - I received this book from the publisher but I am not required to requite a positive review. I always give brutally honest reviews and attempt to critically point out parts of the book that may non agree with the Bible then not appeal to others. I want you readers to exist able to confidently choose a volume based on the stars I give it, because I know you take limited money, time and energy to read. Then let's make the near of our lives and discern and cull the very all-time books wisely.
If you disagree with whatever bespeak in whatsoever of my reviews, please in a loving, edifying and respectful manner, write me "as y'all wish someone would right yous" in detail pointing out exactly what you call back I missed. I long to be sharpened. God bless.
...more3.5 stars -- I love the idea of a 40-24-hour interval prayer challenge; it's just the kind of thing I needed to exercise during the Lenten season. Simply like a lot of other reviewers, I was expecting more of a "pray about this topic today," "pray nearly that topic today," then the structure of the book threw me off a little. Just it's not fair to guess a book based on my expectations.
It is definitely encouraging to read stories of God showing upward for
Information technology is weird to charge per unit your pastor's volume, only I'thou going to practice it anyway:3.5 stars -- I love the thought of a 40-day prayer challenge; it's just the kind of affair I needed to do during the Lenten season. But like a lot of other reviewers, I was expecting more of a "pray about this topic today," "pray about that topic today," so the construction of the book threw me off a footling. Simply it's not fair to gauge a book based on my expectations.
Information technology is definitely encouraging to read stories of God showing up for other people. That aspect of the book, without a doubt, increased my faith. And I institute myself praying for things that I wouldn't have thought to pray for otherwise. So, it's definitely a great book in that regard. Just the lack of structure didn't actually exercise it for me.
...moreThe more I read this volume, the more I believe in the power of prayer. When nosotros pray, God volition open doors co-ordinate to His will. Actually, He answers in ways we can never imagine. Pray through and God volition break through!
It will bless you. It's worth every penny! Invest in your prayer life and fight for what you lot want. Matthew 7:seven all around. Enquire, Seek, and Knock!!!! Go on on pressing for information technology!!!!
...moreNews & Interviews
Welcome back. Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads business relationship.
Source: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/16182599-draw-the-circle
0 Response to "Draw a Circle Theologic Review"
Post a Comment